
The US government has appealed the court order that stopped its duration of status rule, the rule that would end open-ended stays for F-1 students, J-1 exchange visitors and foreign journalists on I visas. F-1 is the visa most Indians hold for a US degree. The Department of Homeland Security, or DHS, filed the appeal on 30 September 2026, and the federal appeals court opened it as case 26-2112 the next day.
Nothing changes for Indian students while the appeal runs. OPT is the work permission that follows a US degree, and an F-1 student can still stay as long as they study full time, plus 60 days after the course or OPT ends. No new form is due, and nobody’s time in the US has been cut to four years. The appeal decides whether that four-year limit comes back, so a student in the US now, or one planning a US master’s for 2027, can plan on today’s rules while following the case.
What did the US government appeal in the duration of status case?
DHS, its enforcement agency ICE, Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin and acting ICE director David Venturella appealed the 48-page order that Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV issued on 14 September 2026 in the federal court for the District of Massachusetts. The case is Presidents’ Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration v. DHS, brought by groups representing almost 600 colleges, including NAFSA, the association of international student advisers, and by unions of teachers, graduate workers and journalists.
The notice of appeal is two pages long and gives no reasons, which is normal at this step. The arguments come later in written briefs. Two courts now have the case at once, and the table shows where each one stands.
| Date | What happened | What it means for an F-1 student |
|---|---|---|
| 17 July 2026 | DHS publishes the final rule, due to start on 15 September | A four-year limit on F-1 stays is announced |
| 14 September 2026 | The Boston court postpones the rule nationwide, one day before it starts | Duration of status continues |
| 30 September 2026 | DHS files its notice of appeal | No change |
| 1 October 2026 | The First Circuit opens case 26-2112; first forms due 15 October | No change |
| 2 October 2026 | The judge holds a status conference; a proposed schedule is due by 9 October | No change |
The First Circuit is the federal appeals court that hears appeals from Massachusetts. What matters most in the coming weeks is whether DHS asks it for a stay pending appeal, which is a request to pause the judge’s order while the appeal is heard. On 3 October, neither the district court docket nor the appeals court docket showed one. Without that pause, the order holds for as long as the appeal lasts.
What would the duration of status rule change for an F-1 student?
The rule would replace an open-ended stay with a fixed end date. Today an F-1 student’s stay lasts as long as they study full time, with no date on it. Under the rule, the stay would end on the course end date on the I-20, capped at four years, plus 30 days, and anything longer would need USCIS approval.
Duration of status, written “D/S”, is what appears today in the “admit until” field of your I-94, the US government’s electronic record of your entry. The I-20 is the form your university issues to show your course and its dates. USCIS is the agency that decides immigration applications made from inside the US, and STEM OPT is a further 24 months of OPT for graduates in science, technology, engineering and maths. The final rule, published on 17 July 2026, would make these changes for a student.
| Rule area | Today, under duration of status | Under the rule, if it returns |
|---|---|---|
| How long an F-1 student may stay | As long as you study full time, with no end date on the I-94 | The course length on your I-20, up to 4 years, with a fixed date on the I-94 |
| Time to leave after the course or OPT ends | 60 days | 30 days |
| OPT and the STEM OPT extension | Apply for the work permit only | Also apply to USCIS to extend your stay, with a fee and fingerprints, or leave and re-enter |
| Needing more time to finish | Your university adviser extends your I-20 | USCIS must approve an extension, only for academic, medical or reasons beyond your control, and a refusal cannot be appealed |
| A second degree at the same level, or a graduate transfer | Allowed | Not allowed, except in unusual circumstances the rule lists |
| J-1 exchange visitors | The length of the programme | The programme end date, up to 4 years |
| I visas for foreign journalists | The length of the assignment | Up to 240 days |
Based on the final rule, 91 FR 44976, sections 214.2(f), (i) and (j), and the court’s summary of it, read on 3 October 2026. None of the right-hand column applies while the court order stands.
The change that would reach most Indian graduates is OPT. A two-year MS student on a fixed date would have to ask USCIS for more time before starting OPT, on top of the OPT application itself. The judge also noted DHS’s own words on refusals of these requests, “decisions may not be appealed”, which is why PhD students worry most. A research doctorate takes a median of 5.7 years, according to a NAFSA comment the order quotes.
The rule also set fixed dates for students already in the US. Anyone maintaining F-1 status on 15 September 2026 would have kept the old terms until their I-20 end date or work permit end date, but not past 14 November 2030. Those dates are written into the rule itself, and nothing DHS has published says how they would move if the rule came back later.
Why did the Boston court postpone the duration of status rule?
The judge found that DHS had probably broken the Administrative Procedure Act, the US law on how agencies make rules, because it did not properly explain its reasons for this one. He did not rule that limiting student stays is beyond DHS’s power. He ruled that DHS skipped the analysis a rule this large needs, and he found four failures.
- DHS did not weigh costs against benefits. It called a fall in international enrolment “speculative” and so counted the cost as nothing.
- It brushed aside other options, such as tighter checks through SEVIS, the database that already tracks every F-1 student.
- It gave brief, dismissive answers to serious public comments, out of about 22,000 received in 32 days.
- It never showed how a four-year limit would stop the security and fraud cases it cited. On national security, the judge wrote that the government’s case “borders on the absurd”.
The relief is nationwide. DHS asked the judge to protect only the plaintiffs, but he wrote that the plaintiffs speak for almost 600 of the more than 5,000 US colleges, and that two sets of rules for students who transfer between them would cause “chaos and confusion”. The two-page order that came with the ruling says exactly what is stopped.
The effective date of the Final Rule is hereby POSTPONED pending further order of this court or resolution of this proceeding on the merits. Defendants are preliminarily enjoined from taking any further action to implement the Final Rule pending further order of this court or resolution of this proceeding on the merits.
US District Court, District of Massachusetts, preliminary injunction order, 14 September 2026
In plain terms, the rule hasn’t started, and DHS can’t take steps to start it. The judge did not cancel the rule, which is called vacating it. He turned that request down for now and left it open, so the case can still end with the rule struck down for good. DHS has been blunt about its view. Its general counsel, James Percival, was quoted by The PIE News on 15 September saying that under the ruling a student could “take one class per semester, and stay here for decades”.
What should Indian F-1 students do while the duration of status appeal is pending?
The only steps worth taking are ordinary ones, staying enrolled full time and making sure your I-94 still shows D/S, because the old rules still apply in full. If you are in the US on an F-1 visa, there’s no new form to file and no deadline to meet, and a student planning a 2027 start applies exactly as before.
Your I-94 can be downloaded from the I-94 website of US Customs and Border Protection, the agency that admits you at the airport. After any trip abroad, the record should show “D/S” in the “admit until” field, the way the SEVP FAQ describes the old system. If it shows a fixed date instead, your university’s international student office is the place to raise it.
| Your situation | What applies today | If DHS wins the appeal |
|---|---|---|
| On an F-1 visa in the US, with D/S on your I-94 | Duration of status, nothing to file | You keep the old terms until your I-20 end date, though the rule’s dates for current students may be reset |
| Finishing a degree and applying for OPT or STEM OPT | The OPT application alone, 60 days to leave after OPT ends | A separate USCIS request to extend your stay, and 30 days to leave |
| Starting a US master’s in Spring or Fall 2027 | D/S if you arrive while the order stands | A fixed date on your I-94 at arrival, so OPT needs an extension request |
| Planning a second master’s or a change of university | Allowed | Not allowed, except in unusual circumstances the rule lists |
| In a PhD, or any course longer than four years | No limit while you study full time | A USCIS extension before year four, which can be refused with no appeal |
One source can mislead you right now. Study in the States, the student pages run by SEVP, the DHS office that oversees F-1 students, still describes the rule as coming. Its quick facts page was last updated on 10 September, four days before the order, and says nothing about the court. Students reading it today would think they need an extension for OPT. They don’t. The same goes for the eCFR, the government’s online copy of US regulations, which has shown the new four-year wording in section 214.2 since 15 September with no note of the court order.
For students choosing a course, the OPT and STEM OPT rules on our site describe today’s system, which is the one in force. The visa interview and the F-1 visa itself are unchanged too, because the rule governs how long you may stay after you land, not who gets a visa. A student weighing a two-year MS in the USA against a longer course should know that a PhD or a five-year programme carries the most risk if the rule returns.
Our view: will the duration of status rule come back before 2027 admissions?
Our read is that the rule is unlikely to apply to anyone before the appeals court decides, and that decision is probably months away. That is a judgement about timing, not a forecast of who wins. The government has every right to appeal and could win, so the rule is paused, not dead.
Three things shape that view. DHS waited 16 days to appeal and, as of 3 October, had not asked for a pause, which is the only fast route to bringing the rule back. The same appeals court refused DHS a pause on 24 July 2026 in the H-1B fee case, which our report on the second H-1B fee ruling covered. And the judge’s ruling rests on how DHS made the rule, so even a DHS win would leave the case running in Boston.
For a student deciding on a Fall 2027 start, we wouldn’t change course choices because of this rule alone. We would think harder about a PhD or a course longer than four years, where a refusal of more time could end a degree, and we would keep an eye on the 9 October schedule. Several things are still unknown on 3 October 2026.
- Whether DHS asks the First Circuit to pause the order, and how fast that court rules on it.
- What schedule the parties propose on 9 October, and whether the judge moves to cancel the rule outright.
- How DHS would reset the rule’s fixed dates, such as 15 September 2026 and 14 November 2030, if it wins.
- When SEVP updates Study in the States to reflect the court order.
- DHS appealed on 30 September 2026 against the 14 September order that postponed its rule ending duration of status, and the First Circuit opened case 26-2112 on 1 October.
- The order is nationwide, so F-1, J-1 and I visa holders are still admitted for duration of status, and F-1 students keep 60 days to leave after a course or OPT ends.
- If it returns, the rule would cap an F-1 stay at four years, cut the time to leave to 30 days and make OPT depend on a USCIS extension of stay.
- As of 3 October 2026, no request to pause the order during the appeal appeared on either court’s public docket.
- Study in the States still describes the rule as coming and has not been updated since 10 September, so it does not reflect the court order.
Frequently asked questions
Is duration of status still in place for F-1 students?
Yes. The Boston court postponed the rule on 14 September 2026, one day before it was due to start, and barred DHS from putting it into effect. The appeal filed on 30 September does not change that. F-1 students are still admitted for duration of status, and their I-94 should show D/S as before.
Do I need to file Form I-539 before starting OPT now?
No. Form I-539 is the USCIS application to extend a stay, and the rule would have required it for OPT. Because the rule is postponed, OPT works as it did before, with only the work permit application on Form I-765. Study in the States pages still say otherwise because they predate the court order.
Will the four-year limit apply to students starting in Fall 2027?
Nobody knows yet. It applies only if DHS wins the appeal, or a pause of the order, before you arrive, and DHS has not asked for a pause so far. If the order still stands when you land in 2027, you are admitted for duration of status. If the rule returns, your I-94 would carry a fixed date.
Is it safe for an F-1 student to travel outside the US during the appeal?
The appeal adds no new travel risk, because the order bars DHS, which runs entry at US airports, from applying the rule. A returning F-1 student should be admitted for duration of status. The usual checks still apply, a valid visa and an I-20 signed for re-entry by your university, and it is worth downloading your I-94 after you land.
What is the difference between postponing and cancelling the rule?
A postponement pauses the rule until the court decides or orders otherwise. Cancelling it, which lawyers call vacating, would strike it down. Judge Saylor chose the postponement on 14 September and left vacating open for later, so the case in Boston continues alongside the appeal and could still end with the rule struck down.
Sources
All sources read on 3 October 2026.
- US District Court, District of Massachusetts, Presidents’ Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration v. DHS, No. 1:26-cv-13799-FDS, memorandum and order on motion for preliminary injunction, 14 September 2026 and the preliminary injunction order postponing the effective date of the final rule
- Notice of appeal, 30 September 2026, and the district court docket, entries 53 to 56
- US Court of Appeals for the First Circuit, No. 26-2112, docketed 1 October 2026
- DHS, Establishing a Fixed Time Period of Admission and an Extension of Stay Procedure, final rule, 91 FR 44976, 17 July 2026
- SEVP, Study in the States, final rule quick facts, last updated 10 September 2026 and FAQ, last updated 31 August 2026
- US Court of Appeals for the First Circuit, California v. Mullin, No. 26-1699, order of 24 July 2026 denying a stay
- US Customs and Border Protection, I-94 website
- Higher Ed Dive, “DHS appeals decision blocking 4-year cap on student visas”, 1 October 2026
- The PIE News, “Temporary win for sector in duration of status lawsuit”, 15 September 2026
